Guideline
for Reviewers
As
a Reviewer to use this Online Submission & Review System, you must have Adobe®
Reader® installed
on your computer, by which the manuscript PDF can be opened.
The
review process may be described as follows:
1. You, as a Reviewer, must first log into this Online Submission & Review System with the account and password listed in the invitation email from the PC member.
2. After you fill in the personal information, you are authorized to review
those manuscript(s) allocated to you.
3. All
the PC members may distribute the manuscript(s) to you for reviewing, but you
can either Agree or Decline to review the manuscript(s).
4. If
you agree to review the manuscript, you
can download
it for reviewing. After the review process has been finished, you can upload
your review report by this Online
Submission & Review System.
5. You
can also check your review history and modify your personal information if you
please.
In
the following, the left navigation menu for Reviewer section would be explained
in details as follows.
Home:
Go
back to the Homepage of ICIC.
Guideline:
Tutorial for Reviewers.
Confirmation:
This section function is to confirm whether or not you would like to review the manuscript
allocated to you, see Figure 1 . If you choose ¡°Agree¡±, a
popup window will be shown to you,
where you can choose ¡°Yes¡° or ¡°No¡± to decide whether or not you would
like to review this manuscript. If you choose
¡°Decline¡±, you may be asked to provide information
regarding your decision to decline the invitation and at the same time to
suggest alternate Reviewer who may be available to review the manuscript. And
then an email will be automatically by our system sent to the PC member who
distributed you the manuscript, which shows him your decline information.
Figure 1
Review
Report: This
section function is to write
your review report,
see Figure 2. You
can right click 'Paper Title' and choose 'Save as ' to download the manuscript
for reviewing! Click the button ¡°Start to
review¡±, a
popup window will be shown to you,
where you can rate
the manuscript on a scale of 1-5, 1: very poor ,2:poor, 3:fair,
4: good, 5: excellent. In particular, for convenience, the five rate
criterion as well as the proficiency to the paper can be abbreviated as follows:
A:
Originality;
B: Significance of Topic;
C: Technical Quality;
D: Relevance to the Conference ;
E: Presentation;
F: Proficiency;
Figure
2
Finally,
please don¡¯t forget to insert your confidential comments to the author if
necessary (note that your name will not be released to the author).
Once
you have submitted out your review report,
the submission will be moved into the ¡°History¡± link,
and no further action is required for this Online Submission & Review
System.
History:
A
manuscripts list which shows that you have reviewed, see Figure 3.
Figure 3
Personal
Info: You
can change or update your personal details (including your password, address,
etc.) by clicking on the ¡°Personal Info¡± link once you log in.
Log
Out: Exit
from this Online Submission & Review System.